your student is dreading this question


"What did you do over break?”

​
Sounds like such an innocent question, right? It seems like it's a great way to reflect on vacation and have students share.
​
But there's a student who might be waiting for the ground to swallow them when you ask this.
​
A teacher once told me that every year, knowing her mother was sick and her family could not afford trips, she would calculate when it would be her turn to share about her break. As the moment got close, she would raise her hand, rush to the bathroom, and stay there until she knew her turn had passed.
​
​And it was not just her.​
​
When I shared this story (with permission), another teacher reached out with her own memory. She remembered how some amusement parks tied a string in your hair to show you had paid the entrance fee. So she cut a piece of string, put it in her hair, and made it look like she had gone somewhere too.
​
It is a delicate balance. We want to raise kids who are resilient and kids who are sensitive. We want them to focus on what they have, not only what they do not have. And I am not negating that.
​
​3 suggestions of what you can do that go with that balance.​
​
1. Give students a journal / do now prompt that asks them about their break in a private written way instead of in a way that opens the door to comparison. (From the teacher who told me the story from earlier). Offer a choice of prompts for them to choose from.
​
2. Ask them to share if there was something over break that happened or that they saw that reminded them of something from the school year. Before doing this, clearly state your expectations such as how long each student has (and perhaps a visual timer) and accepted responses.
​
3. And this third one, thank you Aidele Vigler who shared: Share something meaningful or fun that YOU did on your break (that is free!), like playing a new game or family you got to see, before asking them about their break. This sets the tone. And as students share, be intentional with your reactions. Notice the meaningful moments.
​

Mushkie
@evergrowingeducator
​
PS: Was this email forwarded to you? Now that’s a great friend/boss/co-worker! Sign up for resources + classroom mindset here.
​

​

Evergrowing Educator

If you love teaching, learning new things and bringing creativity and engagement into your classroom, then you're an ever growing educator, too. HI! 👋🏻

Read more from Evergrowing Educator

(Scroll down for the NEW monthly teacher planner!)There’s this joke I’ve told my students: There was a man who loved archery. He was always looking for new tips and tricks. One day, he was walking through a forest and saw a house with bullseyes everywhere. Dead center. Every. Single. One. He knocked on the door and asked the man who lived there, “How do you do it? I’ve never seen aim like that.”The man smiled and said, “Oh, it’s easy. First I stick the arrow in the wall. Then I draw the...

“Can you put us into chatgpt and turn us into lego people?” my kids, huge lego fans, asked me.I explained to them why I wouldn’t do that. Anything uploaded to ChatGPT is stored on OpenAI’s servers and I wouldn’t upload photos of kids (or my students!) to ChatGPT! It did spark an idea though. A few months later, I took out a large canvas and pencil and I outlined lego people, one for each person in our family. Each kid then painted themselves, with their favorite outfit choice, their faces,...

I’ve been seeing this a lot on my feed these days: Definitely been feeling this, too - I’ve been meaning to email all month... and it’s just been a holiday for the past few weeks 🙂 Now that Tishrei is behind us and school is fully back, I’ve been thinking about my own personal “V’Yaakov Holach L’darko” I was listening to a podcast with Carol Dweck, and she was remembering how her middle school classroom was arranged based on perceived intelligence! Imagine having your seat determined by your...